Loading...

La vision de PGA est de contribuer à la création d'un ordre international fondé sur le respect des règles pour un monde plus équitable, sûr, durable et démocratique.

PGA calls for an informed parliamentary debate on domestic implementation of the Rome Statute into Malaysian Law and for a reversal or, at least, a suspension of the decision to exit from the ICC

Accession was due to enter into effect on 1 June

Parliamentarians for Global Action (PGA) has been observing with respect the internal debate that has taken place in Malaysia after the decision taken by the Cabinet to accede to the Rome Statute of the ICC since the end of 2018, followed by the deposit of the instrument of accession at the UN on 4 March 2019 and by today’s Cabinet decision to withdraw the said instrument before its entry into force on 1 June.

In Malaysia, being a parliamentary democracy with a federal constitutional monarchy, the Constitution vests the nominal executive authority of the Federation to the King (Yang di-Pertuan Agong). However, the King is bound to act in accordance with the advice of the Cabinet (or of a Minister acting under the general authority of the Cabinet), headed by the Prime Minister. The King, as the Head of State, is bestowed with functions relating to representation and limited discretionary powers under the Constitution.

It is the understanding of PGA that the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) does not limit in any manner the constitutional prerogatives of the Monarch. As stated by representatives of the Malaysian Executive, the Monarch was duly informed of the Cabinet decision ahead of the implementation of the decision, and did not object. The Executive waited more than two months to implement the decision. Conversely, media sources reveal that the committee of the Conference of Rulers (Sultans) – a collegiate sui generis body that includes the rotating King – should have been asked to approve the decision to accede to the Rome Statute on the purported argument that the Statute amounts to a limitation of the Rulers’ privileges. As explained by the Foreign Minister and other Malaysian authorities, including the highest legal officer of the State (the Attorney General, who is not a member of Cabinet), the Rome Statute of the ICC does not entail any inconsistency or incoherence with the Malaysian Constitution and does not erode any privilege of the Rulers.

The Prime Minister of Malaysia announced at the September 2018 session of the UN General Assembly that the new Government of Malaysia would have joined international human rights treaties. This has spurred a national debate started in Malaysia regarding the International Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD), the ratification of which might indeed have an impact on certain provisions of the Malaysian Constitution that recognize, in a distinct manner, diverse racial or ethnic groups. In a recent statement, a member of the Conference of Rulers conflated the two treaties and labelled the Prime Minister as potentially liable if the Constitution would have been violated by joining the Rome Statute and the ICERD.

PGA calls the Prime Minister of Malaysia and its Cabinet to reconsider today’s decision, which appears to be the result of misunderstandings and confusion. In doing so, it is humbly submitted that the following arguments may be considered:

  1. The Rome Statute protects the victims of genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and aggression: As such, it does not collide with any provision of the Malaysian Constitution. Conversely, it provides with an additional guarantee that justice will be rendered when the most serious crimes of concern that shock the consciousness of humankind are committed, including when victims are Muslims. Therefore, the purported threat posed by the Rome Statute to Islam is absolutely incorrect and is the consequence of false information. In fact, several Muslim-majority States are parties to the Rome Statute of the ICC, which counts on 122 member states.

  2. The Rome Statute is an international treaty that can be lawfully ratified by an act of the Executive under the Constitution of Malaysia. Given that it does not modify or alter any constitutional provision within the Malaysian legal order, any reference to treason or other cause for dismissing the democratically elected Government in the absence of consent by the Conference of Rulers is unfounded and appears instrumental to the opposition to other treaty ratification processes.

  3. Parliament shall be engaged in the discussion on the Rome Statute with the specific purpose to consider draft legislation aimed at implementing the Rome Statute provisions into national law: Such a debate may bring about the enactment of legislation that will also certainly implement fundamental principles of justice contained in the Malaysian Constitution, hence clearing the way for any possible misunderstanding or mischaracterization of legal norms and obligations.

In light of these points, Parliamentarians for Global Action respectfully submits that the Government of Malaysia reverse or, at least, suspends the effects of today’s decision on withdrawal from the notice of accession deposited on 4 March, which will not be in force until 1 June 2019, and await that Parliament considers the relevant legislation before giving effect to an informed and final decision about remaining in, or exiting from, the Rome Statute system against impunity for the most serious international crimes.

Download the Press ReleaseDownload the Press Release

Dernières Nouvelles : Campagne sur le Statut de Rome de la CPI

"Verkhovna Rada" by Martin Schulz is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0.

On 21 August 2024, with an overwhelming 281 votes in favor out of 328 MPs present, the Verkhovna Rada adopted the Law to Ratify the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court and its amendments.

July 22-24, 2024 visit by Ghana Delegation to The Hague

The visit aimed to provide the MPs with comprehensive information and address questions concerning the draft bill to implement the provisions of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC) at the national level.

From 28 to 30 May 2024, Parliamentarians for Global Action (PGA) organized an important visit of Somali Members of Parliament to The Hague, Netherlands

The delegation – all members of the Committee of Justice and Defense from the Federal Parliament of Somalia – had the opportunity to engage in direct and crucial exchanges on accountability and justice.