On 28 April 2021, the Supreme Court of Appeal of Malawi declared the death penalty unconstitutional as an impermissible derogation from the right to life under the Malawi’s Constitution. This decision equates to de jure abolition. All statutes prescribing the death sentence are effectively amended so that life imprisonment constitutes now the maximum sentence in Malawi.
This decision has been strongly welcomed by PGA members worldwide:
I wholeheartedly welcome this landmark decision and applaud Malawi for becoming the 22nd country in sub-Saharan Africa to abolish the death penalty, following Chad’s abolition of capital punishment for all crimes last April. This decision should also encourage all States to ratify the Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, aiming at the abolition of the death penalty. There is absolutely no reason for States to maintain capital punishment in their jurisdictions: it has no deterrent effect and all legal systems are bound to make mistakes – even when due process and legal safeguards are respected. Mr. Mark Pritchard, MP (UK), Chair of the PGA National Group in the UK, Member of PGA Executive Committee
The next steps will involve the resentencing of those under sentence of death to alternative sentences. At the end of 2020, 27 people were known to be under a death sentence in Malawi. Although executions had not been carried out in Malawi since 1975, Malawi was still a retentionist country.
I commend the decision of the Supreme Court of Malawi. Declaring the death penalty unconstitutional is a crucial step towards improving the protection of human rights and to uphold justice. While there has been a moratorium on executions since 2017 in my country, Malaysia, there are currently more than 1280 individuals who are currently on death row for various crimes. Some inmates have been on death row for decades and yet the numbers keep increasing. It is a well-documented fact now that the death penalty is not a deterrent, and largely punishes vulnerable people, including minorities and individuals in precarious economic situations. I strongly call on all retentionist States in all regions of the world, including in Africa and South-East Asia, to follow the example of Malawi and move towards the abolition of the death penalty in their jurisdictions. I hope the Malaysian Government will look into investing in restorative justice and move away from the death penalty. Governments must start to act against corruption, injustice and abuses of power instead of ending livesMs. Kasthuri Patto, MP (Malaysia), Deputy-Convenor, PGA International Law & Human Rights